Consumer

The 2026 Holiday Shopping Season: What Marketers Need to Know Right Now

Consumers are spending carefully, AI is reshaping how they discover products, and retailers are still fighting over who gets to close the sale. Executives across the industry weigh in.
The 2026 Holiday Shopping Season: What Marketers Need to Know Right Now

Consumers are spending carefully, AI is reshaping how they discover products, and retailers are still fighting over who gets to close the sale. Executives across the industry weigh in.

The holiday shopping season arrives this year carrying a familiar set of contradictions. 

Consumer sentiment is fragile. A survey from Ideally of 1,100 U.S. consumers found 22% feeling financially stretched, even as “gratitude and hope” lead the emotional mood heading into Christmas. Spending is expected to hold, but every dollar will be more deliberately placed than it was a year ago. 

Meanwhile, AI has swiftly and quietly grown from its early days as a mere novelty to become a  genuine influence on how shoppers find and evaluate products. However,  it has not yet taken over the moment of purchase. This leaves retailers  debating how much of the shopping journey they’re willing to hand to external AI platforms, and on what terms. 

We asked executives across advertising, retail, media, and technology to tell us what they’re watching and what brands should do about it.

‍

The Consumer Mood: Resilient but Deliberate

The headline spending numbers this season are expected to look strong, but the picture underneath is complicated. Sarah Allen, executive brand strategy director at LERMA/, cautions against reading resilience as confidence, specifically when it comes to understanding who’s spending and why. “In this K-shaped economy, that spending is largely carried by higher-income households,” Allen says. “Most people have been under pressure all year, and they’re protecting the holidays the way you protect something sacred: by cutting everywhere else.” Her read is a “make-it-work” holiday: smaller gatherings, store brands in the cart, big purchases pushed to next year, and a lot of energy spent finding the deal that makes the moment feel right. “What they’re protecting is the feeling, not a picture-perfect performance.”

Joshua Nu’u-Steele, co-founder and chief revenue officer at Ideally, sees a similar split in his firm’s research. Gratitude and hope lead how Americans feel about Christmas, yet nearly one in four consumers feels financially stretched. Shoppers plan to spend, but with greater intention than they would in boom times. One shopper plans frugality “This year’s economy is causing a lot of people like me to really cut back on our spending. We don’t know how bad it will get or how long it will go on.” Another captured the planning posture many households are taking: “I will be shopping early but will only have so much money to spend each week for everyone.”

Peter Bray, founder and executive creative director at Bray & Co., observes a pattern in the data that is typical during recessions. “Premium luxury items are still being bought, as are the basic necessities,” Bray says. “It’s the gift items that are priced in the mid-range that will suffer. In other words, be expensive or be cheap, just don’t be in the middle.”

‍

Value, the dominant motivator

Nu’u-Steele’s research found that 47% of consumers said good value for money would make them more interested in buying from a brand after seeing its Christmas advertising. That puts value well ahead of happy Christmas memories at 32% and product discovery at 26%. Jeff Harp, head of west coast sales at Big Happy, puts it simply: “Consumers feel a lot worse than they’re spending.” His read on the season is  strong, but price-driven. “Shoppers are being really deliberate.”

Meanwhile, Jennifer Spire, CEO and partner at Meerkat, points to a generational split worth watching. She expects experiences to outweigh product purchases among Gen Z, who she says would rather put money toward a concert, a trip, or a night out with friends than add another product to their lives. 

On brand loyalty, the picture is mixed. “Brand loyalty definitely still matters for some, but it’s earned and not guaranteed. Millennials in particular don’t demonstrate deep loyalty — evidence suggests they’ll switch for a better deal or a trusted recommendation.”

‍

AI as Research Tool, Not Buyer

The question the industry has been asking about AI shopping agents for the past year, “Will this be the season they finally move the needle on purchases?” is getting a consistent answer from practitioners: not yet, and probably not this season.

Nu’u-Steele’s study found that 55% of consumers have used AI in their path to purchase, but only 7% would buy directly through an AI recommendation. Trust remains thin specifically at the moment of transaction. “This year agents win influence at the research stage, and the checkout stays human,” Nu’u-Steele says.

Allen puts it succinctly: “I’d call this the year agents become the research assistant, not the buyer.” Shoppers are using AI to compare prices and find the right product within budget, but most still want their own hand on the checkout button. The question she hears most from clients has shifted accordingly. “The question we’re hearing from clients isn’t ‘should we use AI?’ It’s ‘will AI find us?’”

Heading into the season, Marco Matos, CEO and co-founder of Adora, was not convinced that agentic buying behavior would shift meaningfully from last year. “Personally I’m still skeptical the trend picks up in buying versus research,” Matos says, “which is where I expect the majority of behavior using AI will shift towards.” His prescription for brands follows from that read: invest in answer engine optimization and content that reaches consumers where they already are, in paid media and daily entertainment, rather than betting on autonomous checkout.

‍

Capturing Early Adopters

Jeanniey Walden, CMO at Fluent, cites Bain research showing that 24% of shoppers plan to start their holiday shopping on AI platforms, up from 17% last year. AI is increasingly a discovery entry point is , she argues, even if the final purchase still happens elsewhere. 

“The opportunity is connecting AI-driven discovery with relevant advertising and seamless paths to purchase, while maintaining the transparency and trust consumers expect.”

Neil Ford, head of central sales at Big Happy, expects AI to shift consumers away from traditional keyword searches and multiple-tab browsing toward more conversational product discovery. The practical effect for brands is that showing up in AI-driven search results becomes as important as showing up in traditional ones. Harp adds a simple observation that captures that awareness dynamic: “ AI, handing an agent your list is like sending a friend to the store — they grab the brand they recognize. So getting known before anyone asks the question goes a long way this year.”

Mark Wahl, VP of technology and innovation at Worst Kept Secret, offers a measured summary of where the season is likely to land. “This holiday season, AI is likely to have far more influence over what people buy than over who or what actually makes the purchase. But while this won’t be the year agentic shopping becomes the norm, it may be remembered as the season when early adopters and the companies that succeed in serving them set the path forward for agentic commerce.”

‍

The Retailer-Agent Standoff

Behind the consumer-facing question of whether shoppers will buy through agents sits a less visible but equally consequential one: whether retailers will let them. The divide between retailers welcoming AI shopping agents and those blocking them reflects competing theories about who should own the customer relationship and the transaction data that comes with it.

Wahl notes that Amazon, eBay, and United Airlines have restricted outside AI agents, citing security and trust concerns, while Walmart and Shopify are embracing AI shopping on their own terms. “Behind these differing approaches is a fundamental question of who controls the transaction and the customer relationship,” Wahl says.

Pat Copeland, general manager of Moloco Commerce Media, sees the retailer dilemma sharpening in 2027. “If the AI interface owns discovery and the recommendation, the retailer keeps the warehouse while somebody else keeps the customer,” Copeland says. 

“Retailers need a clear strategy for determining where external AI platforms fit into their business and where they must own the experience themselves. The ones that treat these platforms as just another traffic source will find out too late that the customer relationship moved somewhere else.”

Scott Kozub, VP of product at Experian Marketing Services, identifies a disconnect in how most retailers are approaching agent readiness. The current advice centers on structured product data, such as schema markup and machine-readable catalogs. But that only addresses half the problem. 

“An agent comparing products on a shopper’s behalf may bring its own understanding of that shopper,” Kozub says. “What it can’t bring is the retailer’s: the loyalty status, purchase history, and household context that turns a generic listing into the right offer.” Retailers treating agent readiness as a catalog project alone, he argues, are solving the easier half of the problem.

‍

What Advertisers Should Do About It

For media buyers and advertisers navigating the season, the practitioners closest to campaign execution emphasize speed, signal quality, and the growing importance of connecting media exposure to actual purchase outcomes.

Todd Porch, CEO of Strategus, reports that AI agents now handle setup and quality assurance for about half of new campaigns at his firm, up from one in five earlier in the summer. But the competitive advantage, he argues, comes from the data behind the automation rather than the automation itself. “AI models are becoming less and less of a differentiator, because everyone has access to the same ones. The competitive advantage comes from the data and infrastructure behind them, and how quickly teams can turn that intelligence into action.”

On CTV pricing, Porch flags a notable pattern: across Strategus’ last five holiday periods, CTV prices during Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday ran as much as 14% above overall fall levels, with last December up 17%. So far in November 2026, prices have held flat, making flexibility valuable. “Advertisers need to be able to revisit plans as the market shifts instead of executing against a media mix that was locked in months earlier.”

Cody Coleman, CEO and co-founder of Coactive AI, sees an opportunity for brands to move beyond genre and show-title targeting in video advertising. “AI can now watch content the way a viewer does, so advertisers can find the exact moments that match their message: a family gathered around the table, a gift being unwrapped, a snowy drive home,” Coleman says. “The advertisers who win this season will be the ones buying moments, not just minutes.”

Measurement is where Kevin Dunn, CRO of Experian Marketing Services, sees an opening forming in real time. When a shopper asks ChatGPT or Gemini for a gift idea, clicks through, and buys, most analytics platforms can’t identify that an AI tool was involved. The sale gets folded into direct traffic or credited to the last channel that touched it, which is often branded search. 

“AI-influenced shopping is still a small share of holiday sales, but it’s growing fast, and it’s being misread at the exact moment retailers are deciding where next year’s budget goes,” Dunn says. “Retailers heading into their January retrospective need a way to look past the last click — connecting identity, media exposure, and outcome to see when last-touch credit doesn’t actually explain a sale — or they will keep funding the wrong channels based on a report that was wrong from the start.”

Ryan Nelsen, CMO of StackAdapt, points to data connectivity as the differentiator in AI-assisted campaign coordination. His firm’s research found that 79% of marketers with connected customer data report improved coordination with AI, compared with 58% of those without that foundation. For holiday advertisers, that coordination becomes more valuable as offers change and shopping windows narrow. “The opportunity is to connect creative development more closely with audience response and campaign performance, helping marketers identify what’s working and adjust creative while a promotion is still relevant.”

Matos offers a final observation that ties the season’s themes together. As consumers spread their attention across more channels and agent behavior shapes more of their decisions, brands face a tighter test of specificity. “They can’t just spray the same generic offers and messages everywhere,” Matos says. “How brands show up on a specific platform and the unique message to match that engagement model matter now more than ever.”

Stay ahead of the story.

Get the latest from The Outcome—expert takes on the industry, emerging trends and exclusive insights into how consumers are actually spending.

Subscribe to The Outcome